Analysis of Power Consumption in Electric Arc Furnace Scrap Steel Smelting

Analysis of Power Consumption in Electric Arc Furnace Scrap Steel Smelting

Characteristics: An electric arc furnace (EAF) is a high-temperature metallurgical furnace that utilizes the heat generated by an electric arc between electrodes and the charged material to smelt ores and metals.

The energy in an electric arc is highly concentrated, with arc zone temperatures exceeding 3000°C. For metal smelting, EAFs offer greater flexibility than other steelmaking furnaces, allowing for effective removal of impurities such as sulfur and phosphorus. Furnace temperature is easily controlled, and the equipment has a relatively small footprint, making EAFs suitable for producing high-quality alloy and carbon steels.

Based on the arc configuration, electric arc furnaces can be classified into three-phase AC furnaces, DC furnaces (consumable or non-consumable electrode), single-phase furnaces, and submerged arc/resistance furnaces.

The furnace body of a typical steelmaking EAF consists of a removable roof, a furnace shell with a slag door, a tapping spout (or bottom tapping system), and a refractory-lined hearth. The furnace bottom and walls are lined with either basic (e.g., magnesia-based) or acidic (e.g., silica-based) refractories.

Electric arc steelmaking furnaces are categorized by their specific transformer capacity (kVA per ton of furnace capacity) into standard power, high power, and ultra-high power (UHP) classes. The process involves feeding electrical energy through graphite electrodes into the furnace. The arcs formed between the electrode tips and the scrap charge serve as the primary heat source.

Since electricity is the heat source, and the furnace atmosphere can be controlled, EAFs are particularly advantageous for smelting steel grades containing easily oxidizable elements. Shortly after their invention, EAFs were adopted for producing high-alloy tool steels and have since evolved into larger, more efficient units.

Comparative Market Perspective and Evolution:

A longstanding industry view held that EAFs, while requiring higher initial investment, produced superior quality steel with precise compositional control. In contrast, induction furnaces (like coreless medium-frequency furnaces) were seen as lower-cost alternatives with limited refining capability (unable to remove sulfur and phosphorus effectively), leading to their association with lower-grade steel products.

However, this perspective is evolving. Driven by factors such as energy savings, emission reduction, and improvements in worker health and environmental conditions, the market dynamics are shifting. In certain applications and regions, induction furnaces are increasingly replacing smaller, less efficient electric arc furnaces.

The quality gap between the two technologies has narrowed significantly. With the selection of appropriate slag formers and refining practices in induction furnaces, the quality of molten steel from modern induction furnaces can approach that of EAFs, albeit with a stricter requirement for high-quality, clean scrap charge. If poor-quality scrap is used, the steel quality from an induction furnace will be inferior to that from a basic (slag-lined) EAF. Conversely, the quality from an acidic (silica-lined) EAF may not surpass that of a well-operated induction furnace.

We are a professional electric furnace manufacturer. For further inquiries, or if you require submerged arc furnaces, electric arc furnaces, ladle refining furnaces, or other melting equipment, please do not hesitate to contact us at  susan@aeaxa.com